Zitat:
> Yes, Yuri on Ice is actually as gay as you think.
I need to say something to the skeptics out there, the ones who are annoyed with YoI, the ones who believe it’s yaoi trash.
Yuri on Ice is quite literally revolutionary so far. It is a big deal. We’re not screaming over some spineless fanservice or some homoerotic subtext. You’ve probably seen the screenshots and gifs out of context and thought, ‘wow, that looks pretty gay.’
No, you do not understand. It is gay.
This is an anime that is not labeled as yaoi- meaning, it is not basic, heteronormative fanservice intended for women with problematic themes. It is not shounen-ai, where it simply teases the watcher for hints of homosexuality but never actually goes through with any of it.
Of course, there is fanservice- butt shots, body shots, what have you- that is skillfully placed in with the rest of the story.
But so far, this show is not queerbaiting.
So far, only three episodes in, Yuri on Ice has been smashing anime stereotypes one after another.
This is unlike we’ve seen in Sports anime. This is almost comparable to No. 6; an anime with a solid, well-done plot that so happens to have a gay romance rather than a straight one. However, Yuri on Ice isn’t just that. There is no doubt this show is one about sexual awakening. That much was painfully clear throughout episode 3.
Not only is it unique that this show is about sexual awakening, but it is between two men. It is very real, very blatant, and not made fun of. It is not a joke. It is not a facade to draw the fangirls in. This is real.
The amount of proof for this is outstanding. The ending song is a great example, from the lyrics to the pictures shown.
‘You’re so beautiful tonight
I was simply entranced
Even the hourglass was
C’mon and take my breath away’
And, as pointed out in previous posts, the act of combing one’s hair is an intimate act between lovers in Japan. That was focused on in the ending sequence of instagram posts.
In episode 3 alone, there was the significant dialogue of Yuri as he skated about how he found his eros in embracing his femininity. That was not made fun of in any way- it was accepted as the right thing, and Yuri felt more comfortable being ‘the woman seducing the playboy,’ the playboy being Victor. If you had any doubt about who the playboy was, Victor’s whistle was a skillful and clever way to give that away all too obviously.
If you haven’t watched Yuri on Ice yet because you believe it’s all fanservice, because you think it is like Free, or Hibike! Euphonium- you are wrong. Both of those shows, while absolutely beautiful and I personally enjoy them both, are constantly skirting around homosexuality. They do everything to imply romantic attraction, but do not actually take the next step. They tease, but don’t give. And this show is not like Haikyuu or any other sports anime, where you can easily see the bonds in the show as platonic or romantic (depending on how you want to think about it).
No, this show is gay, whether you like it or not. You can deny many anime of being gay, as being something only the fangirls are seeing for their shipping desires, but you cannot deny this one.
This is representation, and by god, I hope this show continues to do what it’s doing. If nothing comes of Victor and Yuri’s relationship, this show will still make history as the biggest queerbaiting flop ever seen. And, if it continues to do as amazingly as it is, by god will it be hard to beat.
Eine Reaktion dazu:
Zitat:
Yuuri expressing his femininity is incredibly important. It has been dismissed as stereotypical, as heteronormative, but that is quite backwards from my point originally.
Men expressing femininity is incredibly rare. It’s even rarer in heterosexual men because in the world’s most prominent cultures, masculinity is prized in men and anything otherwise is degraded.
However, it is clear that Yuuri is just beginning to explore his sexual side, his eros, and sexuality is fluid. He has not yet touched on a more feminine part of himself, and was only rigidly thinking about being ‘the playboy,’ meaning that he was trying to channel his masculinity in a sexual sense. However, he realized that it did not work for him and decided to try and channel a more sensual, feminine part of himself.
That is significant, especially through a protagonist of a Japanese anime. Now, as I briefly mentioned earlier, I have showed this series to my gay male friends. I cannot speak for them, as I am a woman, but what I can tell you is that they do feel represented. They get excited with me on Wednesdays, and they feel ecstatic to see a man exploring his feminine side in an anime for once, and not get belittled or treated as a sexual object. They relate to Yuuri, as some of them identify strictly as ‘bottoms’ in sex, as they have expressed to me and to others.
Yes, as much as some people refuse to believe, there are queer men that like to stick to top/bottom roles. They exist. And they need representation as well.
Of course, not every queer, male relationship needs to have a man that is more ‘womanly’ than the other, or more ‘submissive.’ But, it is just as bad to say that there are no queer male relationships that have a man that have traditionally masculine/feminine roles.
Some couples enjoy this, and from a personal perspective as a lesbian (if I have not made myself clear enough already…), I have been in relationships where I am the more masculine one, always, and the reverse- I have been in relationships where I am always the more feminine one. And then, I have been in relationships where I switch between those two energies.
My queer male friends have said they feel the same way. Never, ever say all queer relationships are a certain way. They are all different.
So, on that important note, Yuuri discovers his feminine side. He decides to embrace a woman’s role and seduce Victor.
Is that bad? No. No, it is not. There are queer relationships in real life that are just like this. The queer men that I know personally that have seen this show have relationships like this, and they are more that excited to see this in an anime, for once.
On a final note, the post’s language dismisses eroticism as something bad. Eroticism is an aspect of storytelling and sexual desires are part of life. Not everyone’s life, but it definitely exists for many people. But sadly, some cultures are very touchy about eroticism and see any form of it as bad, as offensive, or as harmful.
Eroticism is a theme explored in this anime. It is not fetishization that degrades queer men- it is something rarely shown so clearly, and now that it is happening, it is a big deal. And it’s great to many queer people out there, including me, who feel like we finally are getting real representation in anime.
It is another queer person’s choice to see it as disgusting and something terrible and harmful. I am sorry to everyone who sees it this way, and I hope you can broaden your perspective to accept expressions of eroticism in shows like Yuri on Ice.